John R QuinnJohn R Quinn
  • Home
  • Home
  • Services
    • Binding Financial Agreements
    • Divorce & Separation
    • Property & Financial Arrangements
    • Wills & Succession Act
    • Children & Parenting
    • Overseas & Expatriates
  • Our Lawyers
  • FAQ
  • News
  • Contact Us
(+61 2) 9283 3344

Judges need more feedback on their work, new research concludes

New research conducted for the Family Justice Council by Professor Judith Masson, from Bristol University – Developing judgement: the role of Feedback for Judges in the Family Court – has been welcomed by Sir James Munby, President of the Family Division.

The research has explored how feedback on the work they do could improve the way judges handle cases about children’s care.

The report notes that being a judge is ‘a very lonely job’ – most judges in the family courts decide cases on their own and have no opportunities to see other judges hearing cases. Unlike professionals in medicine, social work, teaching and many other areas, judges get little or no feedback on the work they do. The research identified several types of feedback that could be helpful for judges, including feedback from observation of their practice, from other judges and court users, and about the effects of court orders on children and families. Being observed and observing other judges encourages self-reflection, and is used in judicial training and development in other jurisdictions, particularly in parts of Australia. Court users, both lawyers and litigants can provide important feedback about whether the judge made their reasons and decisions clear and treated them fairly. Again, such surveys are undertaken in Australia and parts of the USA; court-user surveys in England and Wales have only asked questions about services outside the court room.

The judges who took part in the study were generally positive about the idea of receiving feedback but some were anxious that feedback could leave them feeling less confident in the work they did. Many were interested to know what happened to children involved in their cases but they were clear that feedback about what happened in an individual case could not be allowed to impact on their decisions in future cases: cases had to be decided on their own facts.

The study also included interviews with experienced researchers in family justice. They also favoured judges having feedback to give them a wider understanding of the decisions they had to take. Facts had to be understood in context; for example, what were the usual effects of ill-treatment or particular care arrangements on children of different ages? Researchers thought that findings on children’s development, care and the effects of different court orders should be fed back to judges so that they were better informed when they made decisions.

The report recommends the development of feedback mechanisms for judges including observation and discussion of judicial performance by judges; interdisciplinary discussions of completed cases; court user surveys including questions about experiences in the court room; and better use of data about court proceedings in judicial training. To give judges a better understanding of the decisions in care proceedings, judges should be provided with a research-based guide on the care system.

See the full article at: www.familylawweek.co.uk

Back to News


Contact Us

John R Quinn & Co. Family Lawyers
Level 12, 60 Park Street
Sydney NSW 2000

The closest train stations are Town Hall, taking the Park Street exit, or St James Station, taking the Elizabeth Street exit. John R Quinn & Co. is on the corner of Park and Elizabeth.

Best parking is in the Domain parking station. Take the moving footway and cross Hyde Park to reach our offices.

Phone
(+61 2) 9283 3344
Email
mail@quinnlawyers.com.au
Fax
9283 3366

In The Press

Quebec introduces family law reform, would regulate surrogate motherhood

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

6 new Judges appointed to newly merged FCFCOA

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

Merged court system should benefit vulnerable families

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

FAMILY LAW: Changes to family law in Australia

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers
More

John R Quinn News

John R Quinn & Co welcome Emma Mrakovcic

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

John Quinn is a fellow of the International Academy of Family Lawyers

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

Kevin O'Kane brings Succession Act experience

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers

Landmark cases continue to have impact

October 13, 2016quinn lawyers
More

FAQ

Cost disclosure

What to expect from my first appointment with a lawyer from John R. Quinn and Co.

Why should I use John R. Quinn & Co?

Why use an accredited specialist lawyer when seeking a divorce?

More
John R Quinn & Co. Family Lawyers Logo black
Accredited Specialists in Family Law
© 2020. All rights reserved. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.